Speaking of illusion vs. reality and how the blurring of those boundaries can lead straight to Meadow Glade…
Speaking of illusion vs. reality and how the blurring of those boundaries can lead straight to Meadow Glade…
The bust of Hermes in Russell Edington’s living room, identifies him with that god.
According to Wikipedia, ” The Homeric hymn to Hermes invokes him as the one “of many shifts (polytropos), blandly cunning, a robber, a cattle driver, a bringer of dreams, a watcher by night, a thief at the gates, one who was soon to show forth wonderful deeds among the deathless gods.” He is the guide to the Underworld, the patron of boundaries and travelers, shepherds, herds, thieves, liars, orators, and commerce. He invented several musical instruments including the lyre, the forerunner to the modern harp. Before he was reduced to being Zeus’s errand boy, Hermes was a trickster god and the original sandman, waking and inducing sleep with the touch of his caduseus.
This aspect of Hermes is reflected in True Blood with the emphasis on sleep at Russell’s palace. When Bill arrives at the palace Russell and Talbot put him to bed. During Bill’s second night at the palace, Russell does something extremely odd. After telling Bill to ‘sleep on’ the things they’ve been discussing, he touches his pointed index finger to Bill’s forehead. This is the sandman inducing sleep, bringing Bill the dream that will induce him to change his mind and his loyalties.
One myth that is probably going to come into play is the one about Hermes stealing Apollo’s herd of cattle. There has been a lot of speculation that Russell may have killed Eric’s father Ulfric and stolen a pack of werewolves that he controlled and used for military purposes.
The idea of Russell Edington being the patron of travelers is like Sam’s mother’s repeated declaration that her family are not alcoholics. The very oldest pre-Olympian Hermes was represented by carved phallic stones which were used as boundary markers. One night all these stones in Athens were vandalized. That act set in to motion the events, which led to the execution of Socrates when his pupil, Alcibiades, was implicated in the crime. This bit of history is especially worth noting since Charlaine Harris links Alcide with Alcibiades in a number of ways. First she uses the real Alcibiades’s family and political history as the basis for Alcide’s. She then uses Plato’s fictionalized jealous romantically confused version as the basis for Alcide’s chaotic lovelife and alludes to Shakespeare’s Alcibiades who searches for the lost Bill Timon. The first night at Club Dead when Alcide introduced Sookie to Debbie, twice she is called a prostitute, first by Debbie and later in the thoughts of one of the patrons, alluding to the two acerbic prostitutes who accompanied Alcibiades in Timon of Athens.
Herveux isn’t an authentic surname, so what meaning can be derived from this made up name? ‘Her’ could be traced to Hera the same way etymologists link the first part of the name “Hercules’ with the goddess, and ‘veux’ is French for calf. Alcide’s name indicates that he is the one who is watching over Hera’s Bill’s heifer, Sookie, while he’s away, just like Argus did for Hera. Remember that the possible involvement of Alcibiades in the vandalism against Hermes’s phallic monuments led to the execution of Socrates? Is Alcide implicated in Talbot’s death or the destruction of the palace? Is this what leads to Eric being brought before the magister? . The name Sookie, is used as a cow call in the South to this day. Alcide better watch his back because Russell Hermes killed Argus.
So if Russell is the messenger god Hermes, does the bust in Bill’s office of Artemis in Bill’s study link him with the goddess of the moon and the hunt?
What about the bronze in Eric’s office?
*In the Sookie Stackhouse novels, Alcide was one of Eric’s alter egos, but in the episode 3 postmortem, writer Alexander Woo says that Alide’s character parallels Bill’s in True Blood.
updated 6/30/10
How often are your dreams exact replays of experiences you’ve had? Mine have never been. Have any of the dream sequences in TB been shown to be complete and accurate memories?
Maybe Bill’s other dream from season 1 can give us a clue about what is going on. The day after Gran died, he dreamed that Sookie was sleeping in her bed and someone crept into her room and strangled her.
Bill’s grasp on reality is so poor that neither he nor the audience could determine that it was a fiction until night fell and he was able to go check on Sookie.
So what can we determine from Bill’s dream about returning home to Caroline? Only that it did not happen the way it has been presented to us. However, we may be able to make some assumptions about what was illusion and what was reality.
If the war ended 3 years earlier, why was Caroline greeting visitors with a shotgun? It was not the middle of the night. She’s still dressed. What happened that put that shotgun in Caroline’s hands? In s1 Sookie went for her shotgun when she ‘saw’ René murder Gran in her mind. Was it really the pox that killed little Thomas?
Why does Lorena make a comment about Caroline’s blood, which is designed to entice Bill’s appetite if her purpose is to prevent him from drinking it? When Bill demands that Lorena not harm Caroline, would you expect her reaction to be acquiescence or to exert her power over the situation and him? Dream Lorena is defintely acting out of character. Later Bill assures Caroline that he will not allow Lorena to harm her. Really? How can he prevent Lorena doing anything she likes? Another thing, this is a very different Bill than the one who was so freaked out when Lorena showed up at Godric’s. And speaking of Godric’s, is Lorena the kind of person who shows mercy to the women Bill loves? She tried to rip Sookie’s thoat out and wants to force Bill to watch Russell Edington kill Sookie.
And, why would she want that? Certainly it would make Bill hate her even more, right? Wrong. Lorena knows that she has to provide a traumatic shock to Bill if he is ever going to get over Sookie and leave his humanity behind once and for all. That’s what Tara was reading about in The Shock Doctrine in the pilot episode while she worked at Super Save A Bunch. That’s why after Maudette was found dead, Sookie heard Tara wonder if it would shake Jason up enough to make him finally look at Tara in a romantic light. Lorena is antipicating that if she destroys Bill’s world, she can manipulate him not just into returning to her but falling in love with her. Did Lorena try something similar in the past when Bill kept moaning about his human life?
Bill knows about the shock doctrine, but it’s not book knowledge. It’s experiential. He knew that Sookie would run right into his arms the same day that she buried Gran. Who taught him that leson? Was it Lorena who mercifully made him leave Bon Temps without harming Caroline? Certainly not. You have to tear your subject completely down, take away everything they have and everything they are before you can build them up the way you want them to be. So I ask again, did Lorena prevent Bill from feeding on Caroline?
When Lorena says, “Darling Caroline, I’m so sorry to have to do this to you,” do you really think she was referring to using a bit of glamour so that she wouldn’t remember the trauma of seeing the demon her husband had become? Since when has a vampire shown any remorse about the use of glamour?
Did Lorena cradle Caroline in her arms while Bill, with his insatiable appetite, had his fill, forgetting to stop when he felt Caroline’s heartbeat slow down. Do you think Lorena taught him to watch for that sign and how to force himself to stop by thinking of maggots? I think it’s obvious from Lorena’s past feeding habits and their conduct with the Chicago couple the answer is no.
What is the connection between Eric burying the were in a fresh grave, and a new adult size grave being right behind Bill as he buries his son? Did Lorena teach Bill how best to dispose of the body of his wife that night? If she did, it’s too bad Bill didn’t bother to pass it along that info to his own child. That will come back to bite him, as will his failure to build a real relationship with Jessica, when Franklin exploits Bill’s failings as a maker.
One segment of Bill’s dream is followed by Jason taking the police exam without his pants. This is a clue that Bill’s dream is just as far from reality as Jason’s was.
I’ve added a library page to the menu bar. It is intended to be a running list of all the literature and film that are referenced in SSN and TB. As time permits, I will be explaining the significance of each work to the series.
I think I’ve got all the movies and books that we see in TB with the exception of the first movie Lafayette watches. Is it ‘All About Eve?’
‘
Osterby has completed the massive task of summarizing commentaries for s1 and s2. There is a tab on the menu bar that will take you straight to them for future reference.
Lady, thanks so much for your dedication and diligence. You are awesome!
Revisised 7/10/10
“Can you tell us if this is a picture of you?”
With this question, Mayor Norris passes a Civil War era tintype, labeled, “Mr. W.T. Compton and family” to Bill after his speech to the Descendants of the Glorious Dead.
“Stanley, my boy, is it you?” Olivia asks when she opens the door to Bill after he escapes from Cooter’s Crew.
These questions indicate that Bill’s very identity is at issue, as does the season 3 poster, which depicts Bill with his Civil War regiment. The only problem is that this is not what it shows because Bill’s head has been superimposed onto the body of a Civil War lieutenant. Could the purpose of the horribly Photoshopped poster be to imply that the man who claimed to be Civil War veteran William T. Compton, was actually an impostor?
Arlene indicates that might be the case when she says to Sookie, “I brought him around my kids. I slept in the bed with him, and all that time, it was nothing but lies. His name, his accent. God, you think you know someone. How could I not know?” Of course she is speaking of René, but we know the in addition to being Bill’s patsy for Gran’s murder, he is one of Bill’s major alter egos, and we’ve discussed how Bill changed his accent and his persona after meeting Sookie to fulfill her fantasy of an ideal Southern gentleman. Since Bill and René are alter egos, we could expect more similarities between them beyond their fake accents. Could the name ‘Bill Compton’ be just as phony as the name ‘René Lenier?’
I propose that True Blood is presenting another Martin Guerre. He was a 16th century French peasant who left his family. A few years later, an impostor with detailed knowledge of Marin’s life showed up and assumed his life, suing one of Martin’s uncles for the inheritance from his father’s estate and having two children with his wife.
Many of the stories that are alluded to in True Blood have multiple versions. For example, the movie Psycho was based on the story of a real serial killer and then turned into a book before it was made into a movie. With each new work, the story changes and when considered as a whole, one story with multiple iterations, becomes richer. Martin Guerre’s story fits this pattern because it is part of the historical record that was fictionalized in a novel, turned into the movie The Return of Martin Guerre, and then Americanized in Sommersby with Richard Gere and Jody Foster. The French movie gave Martin a political reason for leaving his family, war, and Sommersby turned it into the Civil War.
So, if the real William T. Compton encountered someone who looked very much like him while he was fighting in the Civil War and told this doppelganger about his life back home, who is the man who assumed his identity and was on his way to claim Compton’s wife and plantation when he encountered Lorena and was made vampire?
I think the obvious answer, based on this post and this one, is that he was a serial killer, probably trying to lose himself in the confusion of war to escape from those who were searching for him. If the man we know as Bill Compton is a serial killer, could he be Johann Schmidt, the Stockyard Bluebeard who immigrated to Chicago from the Mainz-Bingen district in Germany, had a wife named Caroline, and assumed the identities of those he killed? The similarities between his modus operandi and Bill and Lorena’s actions with the Chicago couple are striking if you assume that they impersonated the dead couple and stole their money. Schmidt’s origin near Mainz may be part of the Old Saxon convergence that was discussed on another thread, and also tie in with the researched phenomenon of areas with capital punishment producing a higher than average number of serial killers.*
After Bill left Lorena could he have turned up in history as the Axeman of New Orleans who had a particular fondness for jazz music and claimed to be a supernatural demon from hell?
Alan Ball, like Amy and all good writers, likes symmetry.* An impostor Bill Compton who involved himself in the Civil War and deliberately chose to join the ‘wrong’ side for his own personal reasons smacks of Eric impersonating an SS officer because of his personal vendetta.
Eddie explained to Jason that vampires are what they were when they were turned. Eddie’s doughy body and Franklin Mott’s crooked fangs illustrate that point graphically. With the character of Bill Compton, could True Blood be exploring what would happen if a charming, well mannered sociopathic serial killer were not bound by human limitations.
*The most horrific werewolf trial that ended when the condemned was executed using a Catherine wheel was in Saxony, not far from Mainz, the home of Johann Schmidt. Mainz was also one of the places caught up in the hysteris of the witch trials. One of the factors associated with a higher rate of serial killers is the use of capital punishment by the state.
**Alan Ball often uses symmetrical names to link characters or to make allusions. Consider the Axeman of New Orleans and Eric Bloodaxe, the historical figure Eric Northman is based on, Sookie and Psyche [Sukee and Sykee], Psyche Sookie and Psycho Bill, werewitch and werebitch, Maryann and Sophie Anne, William, Guillaume, and Liam (the French and Welsh versions of William), Eric, Ulfric, and Godric (‘ric’ means ruler). Added: Butt Boy and Bat Boy
by Serena
“In Greek mythology, Dionysus was murdered as an infant and ripped to pieces. The Titans ate every part of him except his heart. His father, Zeus, took the heart and planted it in a woman, Semele. A new Dionysus grew from the heart and was reborn, or “twice born.”
~ an excerpt from the Arcana
A couple weeks ago, it was discussed here and elsewhere the significance of Maryann’s rituals, specifically the rite of Dionysius, the “Hunter Souffle.” From this can be gleamed the following; the eating of the shifter’s heart represented the rebirth of the ‘mad god’ of Maryann, or Dionysus, who is the antithesis of Apollo. And from that we can gleam that the True Blood writers were assigning mythological roles to the characters of Bon Temps. Tara is to Semele, as Daphne is to Daphne, where Sam is to Apollo.
Renée then posited the question about Sam, if his Moon Queen, (whether it be his sister Artemis, the moon goddess Selene, or any of her incantations) had yet appeared. Well, so far as I can tell, she has not, but his Cassandra has appeared. Tara is doubling as Semele and Cassandra, and in this way she too is ‘twice born.’ Or maybe she is ‘twice annihilated’ as in twice cursed.
Apollon, Apollon,
Guard of the ways, my destroyer!
For thou hast quite, this second time, destroyed me.
~Cassandra in ‘Agamemnon’ by Aeschylus, line 1076.
She is the prophetic daughter of the King of Troy, Priam, and his wife Hecuba, (Hecuba it must be noted went mad after the loss of two of her other children and she was turned into a dog, which will be interesting to see how Lettie Mae handles the ‘loss’ of her daughter, if Tara cuts her out of her life. Maybe this is the ‘bad news’ Tara receives at the hospital).
Cassandra has 11 sisters and 50 brothers, most notably Paris, Hector, Polyxena, and her twin brother Helenus (This might represent Lafayette, her brother by another mother, who has the gift but not the curse). Tara also has a large family supposedly, but the rest of siblings have skipped town, though I have to say it can’t be that huge.
There are two different versions of the story of how Cassandra acquired her gift of prophecy. The first one, she fell asleep in Apollo’s temple, who fell into lust with her and made a bargain of granting her the gift in return for sexual favors, she backed out on the deal and he spat in her mouth so no one would ever believe her. (Like with Sam, Tara rejected him, even if they did consummate but I’m ignoring that. I’m also ignoring the fact that Cassandra was only granted her gift by a male god, that’s utter bull-crap, total ancient Greek sexist censoring of a powerful woman. But moving on)…
The second version for our purposes is more interesting. As a child Cassandra fell asleep in the temple of Apollo along with her twin Helenus, while her drunken parents left them behind and returned home. (Lettie Mae!) Apollo’s serpents licked the children’s ears giving them both the gift of prophecy, and when the parents returned the snakes slithered away into Apollo’s laurel grove (Daphne, snake, -sin! ). In this version, its not clear how Cassandra became to be cursed but it is clear her twin brother was not.Regardless, Cassandra became a priestess and entered the employ of Apollo, Sam Merlotte.
Cassandra is best known for her visions of DOOM, the fall of Troy and the Trojan horse. Could Dimitri, the meat tree be a Trojan horse? He was made of wood, and oversized, but he was only a symbolic uterus for Maryann’s ritual. He didn’t contain any spies. Hmm… a Trojan horse probably better applies to Bill Compton. Tara has repeatedly warned Sookie about him and his big bad yet to no avail. But anyway, as we like to say, Cassandra Tara called that shit, and no one believed in her. Alas. So, along came the big bad Greeks vampire, and the fall of Troy Bon Temps was complete. (Well, it was pretty much trashed by the end of season 2 anyway.)
Fasten your seatbelts kiddos, here is where it gets a little weird. Cassandra was ‘raped’ by Ajax the Lesser at Athena’s temple. However, I’ve read that the word rape isn’t particularly used, its more like ‘enslaved’ or ‘claimed’ or ‘violated.’ This is implied within not just ancient texts but there are a few images from pottery that depict sexual domination, but never complete forced penetration… which is pretty much what Franklin Mott is doing to Tara at Sookie’s house. (So does this relate Sookie to Athena?) Mott doesn’t seem to be forcing himself on Tara but he is glamouring her at times, and it does seem like he absconds with her to Russell’s mansion. After the sexual misconduct on Sookie’s stairs, I mean Athena’s stairs, Cassandra is given to King Agamnemnon of the Greeks as a war prize, much like Franklin Mott does in the books; he passes Tara on to Mickey. It remains to be scene what happens at the end of this season. Cassandra eventually gives birth and delivers two boys, twins, that are thought to be Agamemnon’s. (I’ve already said elsewhere I think Tara is pregnant from the Hunter Souffle business, now I’m upping the bet to twins.)
Tara and Cassandra share a lot in common, some wefts of plot are eerily the same. Notice how Cassandra when fleeing from Ajax the Lesser did not run and seek refuge in Apollo’s temple, even though she had become his priestess. She fled to Athena’s instead? Tara did not run to her Apollo, Sam Merlotte, either. She decided to bunk with Sookie. Now you could say that Jason is her real Apollo figure. He fits much better into the sun god role, but Cassandra never idolized Apollo the way Tara does Jason. I think Jason is represented in the hero Aeneas, but that is just a stab in the dark.
Now this brings us to Cassandra in literature. The Oresteia was originally a series of four plays, but only three remain intact. (Interestingly, these plays were originally performed during the Dionysia festival.) Agamemnon, the story of the House of Atreus and Agamemnon’s return home from his victory over Troy is one of them. In the play, Cassandra and her twin boys enter the house only to be slaughtered by Clytaemnestra, Agamemnon’s wife, who has a case of the Debbie Pelts, but worse.
Before Cassandra enters the house, she has a soliloquy in which it appears she goes mad but is in actuality either being possessed by Apollo or a mixture of madness and Apollo. To the audience and the Chorus she seems to be spitting out pure nonsense, but she is seeing the full history of the family of Atrues: their betrayals, sacrifices and cannibalism (heart eating) that has gone on within it. Professor Wikipedia had this to say about her soliloquy, “She evokes the same awe, horror and pity as do schizophrenics,” … “who often combine deep, true insight with utter helplessness, and who retreat into madness,” like Ruby Jean Reynolds.
Psychology is not my forte, but this does fit in with Carl Jung and archetypes, a topic pretty popular in these them parts. Apparently there is a psychological term named after the prophetess, which is referred to as either the Cassandra complex or Cassandra metaphor.
On the checklist for this condition are:
1) Dysfunctional relationships with the Apollo archetype
The Apollo archetype probably deserves its own entry, but wikipedia summarizes it as, “Individuals who resemble Apollo have difficulties that are related to emotional distance, such as communication problems, and the inability to be intimate.” (Sam barks in his sleep, and if he isn’t a loner, I don’t know who is.)
2) Suffering emotionally and physically as well as with bouts of hysteria
(Eggs beat her up; Maryann made her hysterical.)
3) Being perceived as disbelieved.
(‘E-egggz is dead,’ ‘But we’re in the same boat, Bill is missing’ comes to mind, as well as “The Comptons have always had money.”)
Also related to this complex is what is known as the Martha Mitchell effect, which is, according to Wikipedia again, “the process by which a psychiatrist, psychologist, or other mental health clinician mistakes the patient’s perception of real events as delusional and misdiagnoses accordingly.” This is exactly what Tara fears upon entering the mental health facility and in Lafayette’s car. Once she brings up Eggs and Maryann, no one will believe her and she’ll be toast.
Whether Tara actually possesses the true gift of prophecy or just the bold voice to tell it as she sees it, she shares many aspects in Cassandra’s fictional life as well as in the archetype of the angry woman with a history of true hysteria, you know all that black-eyed crap with MaryAnn.
{If you haven’t read the post on Ovid’s Metamorphoses it’s worth a gander, as well as the one on Maryann’s Rituals.}
* ‘Agamemnon’ by Aeschylus as translated by Robert Browning
Yvette–s1 Theodore Newlin’s wife (Eastern European mail order bride?)
Yvetta–s3 Fangtasia werewitch dancer from Estonia
Hank–s1 René’s buddy from Auto Haven
Hank–s3 Trucker killed by Jessica
Traditionally 3 am is thought to have been when Jesus was alone and in need of comfort in the Garden of Gathsemene
1.02 Jason goes to Dawn for comfort after being released from jail at 3 am.
1.05 Tara goes to Lafayette at 3 am after she brings Jason home from the hospital. She takes her anger out on Lafayette and says it makes her feel better.
3.02 Sookie returns from Fangtasia at 5 am, so she must have arrived there around 3 o’clock.
s1 Adele and Bill talk about the Stackhouse family history
s3 Stackhouse family tree is in Bill’s secret file
s1 Tara asks Bill if he owned slaves
s3 Russell and Talbot may have made veiled references to blood slaves
s1 Sookie gets a quick glance at Bill’s office through the window before resting on his steps
s3 Franklin Mott goes through Bill’s office
s1 Bill spied on Sookie before going to Merlotte’s and meeting her.
s3 Mott spied on Bill before going to Merlotte’s and meeting Tara.
s1 Sookie has a deathwish.
s3 Tara has a deathwish.
s1 Sookie involves herself when the Ratts try to drain Bill.
s3 Tara involves herself when the rednecks disrespect Eggs’s memory.
s1 Bill rescues Sookie from the Rattrays.
s3 Mott rescues Tara from the rednecks.
1. Front port conversation
2. Flirting outside late at night
3. Invitation to enter
4. She asks him for help with a investigation involving the supernatural
5. She turns to him when she has lost the person who means everything to her
6. She chides him for ‘talking nasty.’
7. He admits a lie to her. (Bill only when confronted with the truth; Eric of his own volition.)
8. Bill keeps Sookie in the dark about vampires; Eric gives her information about werewolves.
s1 If Bill set her up the first night, Sookie was to be taken from a restaurant by a vampire or his minions, the Ratts.
s3 Bill was taken from a restaurant by wolves.
s1 Bill was expecting Sookie to drink his blood the first night, but his plan was messed up because the Rattrays were V addicts.
s3 Talbot was expecting Bill the previous night, but the werewolves messed up the plan because they were V addicts.
s1 Sookie had to drink Bill’s blood to survive. (s1 commentary confirms that the imagery was meant to sexual.)
s3 Speculation: Bill had to service Cooter to survive.
s1Sookie was bloodied by the Ratts the second night.
s3 Bill was bloodied by the wolves the first and second nights.
s1 Bill killed the Ratts.
s3 Bill and Russell killed wolves.
s1 Bill had a bedroom prepared for Sookie before he met her.
s3 Talbot had a bedroom prepared for Bill before he met him.
s1 Does Sookie sleep in the bed Bill killed Caroline in?
s3 Bill sleeps in Elizabeth Bathory’s bed.
s1 Bill is a reluctant guest at Sookie’s house the night he meets Gran. Tara and Jason invite themselves.
s3 Bill is a reluctant dinner guest at the palace. Lorena invites herself for dessert.
s1 Bill offers Sookie something she’s never had, a real relationship with a man.
s3 Russell offers Bill something he’s never had, a position as sheriff.
s1 Initially Sookie turns Bill down.
s3 Initially Bill turns Russell down.
Does anyone know where I can find Alan Ball’s quote about Tara being a source of truth?
Who has a glove fetish?
In the commentary for ‘Frenzy’ there is a discussion about how this is the second episode in which Jason wears gloves because Ryan Kwanten has a glove fetish and insists on them at every opportunity. This commentary is disengenuos because it’s clear that Ryan isn’t the one with an issue about gloves.
In his commentary for ‘New World in My View,’ Ryan discussed how important this Rambo costume was, how well it was thought out by the costume people, and how carefully it was executed. These fingerless gloves were not just hanging around the set for Ryan to latch on to as was implied.
The commentary was clearly meant to draw attention to how gloves are being used in TB in anticipation of s3, which has more gloves than a dentist’s office.
What is the deal?
Comments (15)